For More Information About The Ada Please Visit Our Website Or Call Our Toll
800-514-0301 and 800-514-0383
24 hours a day to order publications by mail.
M-W, F 9:30 a.m. 5:30 p.m., Th 12:30 p.m. 5:30 p.m.
to speak with an ADA Specialist. All calls are confidential.
For persons with disabilities, this publication is available in alternate formats.
Duplication of this document is encouraged.
The Americans with Disabilities Act authorizes the Department of Justice to provide technical assistance to individuals and entities that have rights or responsibilities under the Act. This document provides informal guidance to assist you in understanding the ADA and the Department’s regulations.
This guidance document is not intended to be a final agency action, has no legally binding effect, and may be rescinded or modified in the Department’s complete discretion, in accordance with applicable laws. The Department’s guidance documents, including this guidance, do not establish legally enforceable responsibilities beyond what is required by the terms of the applicable statutes, regulations, or binding judicial precedent.
Originally issued: July 12, 2011
Therapy Dog Vs Service Dog Vs Emotional Support Dog
Whats the difference between service, therapy & emotional support dogs?
- A service dog is certified and trained to help people with disabilities, such as visual impairments, mental illnesses, seizure disorders, diabetes, etc.
- A therapy dog is trained to provide comfort and affection to people in hospice, disaster areas, retirement homes, hospitals, nursing homes, schools, and more.
- An emotional support animal provides their owners with therapeutic benefits through companionship. They do not require training ,but you may be screened by a mental health professional to see if you qualify.
Emotional Support Animal Training
Unlike service dogs, ESAs do not typically undergo emotional support animal training. While you can certainly enroll your emotional support dog in training classes and get them certified in specific areas, its not expected. More than anything, your ESA is a companion animal who provides comfort in your day-to-day life simply by being a calming presence, rather than performing tasks.
Also Check: What Famous Person Has Schizophrenia
Can The Operator Of A Public Place Require Proof That An Animal Is A Service Dog
A public place can ask only two questions to determine if that individual’s dog is a service dog:
- whether the dog is required because of a disability, and
- what work the dog is trained to perform.
The public place cannot require a person to “prove” that their dog is a service dog. A service dog is not required to be registered, certified, or identified as a service dog. However, in California, pretending to be an owner of a service dog is a criminal misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to $1,000 .
Breeds That Make The Best Emotional Support Dogs
The presence of emotional support animals has become more prevalent in our society. The rise in popularity may be a result of recent studies that show ESAs successfully help people with PTSD, depression, anxiety, and other mental health issues.
In fact, recent studies suggest that within the first week of having an ESA, 82% of individuals with PTSD and other mental health ailments felt their symptoms were minimized.
These adorable and supportive pets can be trained to cuddle, comfort on command, and be highly sociable. While any dog breed can be registered as an ESA, not every breed has the makings of a good emotional support animal . Ive compiled a list of the top 11 breeds that make for the best emotional support dogs.
Read Also: How To Help Health Anxiety
What Ptsd Service Dogs Are Trained To Do
Dogs can be trained as service dogs or provide emotional support as therapy dogs. The main difference between these two breeds of dogs are the kind of assistance they provide to their owners, and what kind of rights theyll have in public. According to the ADA, a service dog is one that has been trained to help someone with an emotional or physical disability that impacts one or more major life activities. If you have been diagnosed with PTSD, you and your certifiably trained service dog may be protected under this act. Emotionally supportive therapy dogs, although life-changing companions, are usually not protected by the ADA, because they havent been formally trained to assist in aiding you in your daily tasks, such as taking medication or overcoming anxiety issues. Whatever education your dog receives, there are several important functions she will perform to help ensure your wellbeing.
Service dogs must have a primary focus on their owner. Although the bond between dog and human is strong and loving, the dog is still on the clock full-time to be alert to cues that indicate her owner is in danger. Even in a social setting where there may be a lot of distractions, the dog must be able to drop everything should her owner suddenly find himself in the midst of a panic attack.
Can My Dog Be A Therapy Dog
If youre interested in volunteering and think your dog may be a great candidate to be a therapy dog, organizations like the Alliance of Therapy Dogs test dog for their suitability and, if accepted, have guidelines that must be followed.
While it doesnt certify therapy dogs, the AKC Canine Good Citizen program offers their training program to organizations, and the CGC test is often a prerequisite required by therapy dog organizations.
What Do I Need To Know About Dogs And Ptsd
Pets, service animals, and emotional support dogs need owners who can provide for them. Dogs require constant attention and care. It is a good idea to discuss getting a dog with your doctor or family before making the decision. If you have PTSD and are worried that it may be hard for you to provide a safe, caring home for a dog, it may be good to wait until after you get treatment for your PTSD and feel better.
You may already have a dog that helps you feel better or do things you would not otherwise do. But learning more about evidence-based PTSD treatments is important. Unlike people who have service dogs because they have permanent disabilities , people with PTSD can get better with treatment.
If you are looking for a service dog or emotional support dog, we recommend you carefully research any organizations you contact. You should only get a dog if you are confident it is well trained. The organization should be able to answer any questions you have.
The Difference Between A Psychiatric Service Dog And An Emotional Support Dog
It is not always clearto staff at public places, and even to some people with disabilitieswhether an animal accompanying an individual with a psychiatric disability or impairment is performing a psychiatric service or “merely” providing emotional support. Confusion may result in unlawful and discriminatory treatment of people with disabilities.
The key distinction to remember is that a psychiatric service animal is actually trained to perform certain tasks that are directly related to an individual’s psychiatric disability. The dog’s primary role is not to provide emotional support. It is to assist the owner with the accomplishment of vital tasks they otherwise would not be able to perform independently. In addition, a psychiatric service dog must not only respond to an owner’s need for help, the dog must also be trained to recognize the need for help in the first place. A dog must be able to respond and recognize to be a service dog.
The animal companionship of an emotional support dog can have genuine therapeutic benefits for individuals with psychiatric disabilities and less severe mental impairments. But unless the dog is also trained to workto independently recognize and respond to its owner’s psychiatric disabilitythe dog does not qualify as a psychiatric service dog and does not receive the protections of the ADA.
History And Research Supporting Assistance Dogs
Guide animals have been referred to in literature and art throughout history, but training schools for service animals first became popularized in Germany in the wake of World War I. Soon after, other countries such as Switzerland, Great Britain, and the United States followed suit. Many of the service dogs who came out of these training programs were paired with veterans, particularly after World War II when rising demand led to many more training schools being opened around the country.
Decades of research support the use of service dogs in assisting individuals with physical disabilities. However, in the field of mental illness, randomized controlled trials lag behind the observable evidence of the transformative support offered by service dogs. The US Department of Veterans Affairs commenced a multi-year study in 2015 to illuminate the benefitsand challengesof canine companionship.
Meg Daley Olmert of Warrior Canine Connection in Baltimoredetails the link between oxytocin, which increases in the human brain through bonding with a dog, and recovery: Oxytocin improves trust, the ability to interpret facial expressions, the overcoming of paranoia and other pro-social effectsthe opposite of PTSD symptoms. Over time, this relationship reduces hyper-vigilance and anxiety, calming the mind and allowing painful memories to reduce their stranglehold on the brain.
What Does A Service Dog Do
There are different types of service dogs. For example, there are dogs that help get a person around if they have eye or heating issues.
Then there are dogs who respond to seizures, and scent-trained dogs who help detect blood sugar levels in those who are diabetic.
There are dogs who help with those who struggle with their mobility and they need assistance in their day-to-day lives.
And lastly, there are service dogs who help those who suffer from mental health problems such as PTSD, panic disorders, autism, anxiety, and even depression.
Recommended Reading: How Does A Panic Attack Happen
What Is A Working Dog
A working dog is a purpose-trained canine that learns and performs tasks to assist its human companions. Detection, herding, hunting, search and rescue, police, and military dogs are all examples of working dogs. Working dogs often rely on their excellent senses of smell to help out where humans fall short. Just a few of the jobs performed by working dogs include:
Since working dogs are usually specifically trained to perform certain roles in certain locations, they are not often subject to legal ramifications. When they are on the job, however, working dogs should not be approached or petted, as doing their job properly requires a high level of focus without distractions.
Ptsd Symptom Specificity Of Trained Tasks
Table 4 contains descriptive statistics regarding the perceived helpfulness of each trained task for individual PTSD symptoms as reported by veterans with a service dog. For each trained task, veterans were asked to indicate which PTSD symptoms they were helpful for . Across the seven trained tasks, there was considerable variability in the number of PTSD symptoms helped. However, the most widely relevant service dog task for veterans PTSD symptoms was calm/comfort to anxiety, with veterans reporting this task to help an average of 12.73 of the 20 PTSD symptoms. This task was perceived as applicable to symptoms across all four symptom clusters. The second most widely relevant task was interrupt/alert anxiety, helping an average of 6.80 of the 20 PTSD symptoms. Most veterans perceived this task as being helpful to several intrusion symptoms as well as symptoms regarding alterations in arousal and reactivity. The task that veterans reported to help the least amount of PTSD symptoms on average was social greeting, helping an average of 1.14 PTSD symptoms. Wake from nightmares was also reported to help only 1.76 PTSD symptoms on average a majority of veterans reporting this task to help with intrusive dreams.
Table 4. Means, standard deviations, and population percentages of the PTSD symptom specificity of trained behaviors.
You May Like: Is Tms Approved For Bipolar
Service Dogs Vs Emotional Support Animals
- Service dogs and emotional support animals have different rights under the law.
- Service dogs perform specific tasks to assist people with disabilities. ESAs provide comfort to people with disabilities mainly through their calming presence.
- In light of new travel rules, most airlines offer special accommodations to trained service dogs only. ESAs and service dogs in training must adhere to an airlines general pet policy.
Why Do I Want An Emotional Support Animal Rather Than Just A Pet
Think of an ESA as a supportive and loving pet that includes legal rights to ensure that you are not separated from their companionship. Because an ESA has been prescribed by a licensed mental health professional for conditions such as PTSD, they are given certain privileges. With a proper ESA letter:
- ESAs are allowed to accompany their owner in the cabin on commercial airline flights under the Air Carrier Access Act.
- Under the Fair Housing Act, ESAs are allowed to live with their owner in housing that has a no pet policy.
- ESAs can access their legal housing and airplane privileges for no charge.
Emotional support animals require no specific training, although they should be well-mannered and under control in public.
Recommended Reading: What Phobia Is The Fear Of Halloween
What Is An Emotional Support Animal
An emotional support dog is basically just what it sounds like. It is a dog that provides comfort, therapeutic effects, or emotional support to someone who is living with a disability.
These dogs are not necessarily trained to do work or tasks like a service dog does. They help people by being there. And, they are a legitimate reasonable accommodation for housing situations. Emotional support dogs are not pets, either.
Its important to note that emotional support dogs are not the only type of emotional support animal. Other kinds of animals may be emotional support animals. One example are cats.
What Disabilities Qualify A Person To Use A Service Dog Or Support Animal
California law typically offers greater protection than federal law for persons with disabilities. For example, California defines “disability” more broadly than the ADA does. Under the federal ADA, a physical or mental impairment qualifies as a disability only if it “substantially limits” a major life activity. In California, a physical or mental impairment need only limit a major life activity, which simply means that the impairment must make the achievement of the major life activity difficult.
In California, a mental disability includes any mental or psychological disorder or condition–such as intellectual disability, clinical depression, bipolar disorder, organic brain syndrome, emotional or mental illness, or specific learning disabilities–that limits a major life activity. A major life activity refers to physical, mental, and social activities and working. California does not, however, consider compulsive gambling, kleptomania, or unlawful substance use disorders to be mental disabilities.
You could be eligible for up to $3,345 per month In SSDI Benefits
Also Check: Can You Have Ptsd From A Relationship
Importance Of Trained Tasks And Frequency Of Task Use
Table 2 displays descriptive statistics of perceived importance and frequency of use of service dog trained tasks. Overall, participants with a service dog reported using a trained task an average of 3.16 times a day . Veterans with a service dog rated calm/comfort to anxiety as both the most important task and the most frequently used task. Similarly, cover and interrupt/alert to anxiety were rated as the second and third most important and most frequently used tasks, respectively. Block to create space and block to guard/protect were rated nearly identically for both importance and frequency. Veterans rated the service dogs social greeting task as the least important behavior for their PTSD and the second least frequently used task. Perceived importance of the social greeting task had the largest variance among veterans with a service dog, indicating the most individual variability in responses. The least frequently used service dog task from veterans was wake up from nightmare. It is notable that even the lowest-rated tasks were still perceived on average as moderately important for veterans PTSD. Overall, waitlist expectations of importance and frequency of use of trained tasks tended to be higher than what was experienced among veterans with service dogs .
Table 2. Means, standard deviations and group comparisons of the expected and experienced importance of trained tasks for PTSD symptoms and frequency of trained task use per day.
What Services Do Ptsd Dogs Offer
These particular service dogs who are trained to help people with the disability of PTSD are also used to reduce stress and help a person interact socially. They can:
- Help in a medical crisis
- Give reminders that meds need to be taken
- Offer security if anxiety or fear strikes
- Assist in dealing with emotional trauma through companionship
These dogs can complete goal-oriented tasks as required but actually,do further unintentional work by changing the chemistry in their handlers brain through enhancing the production of oxytocin. This chemical in the brain promotes bonding and trust and is heightened when people have interaction with babies, dogs, and other creatures that are cute and evoke a feeling of pleasure. This ability to heighten oxytocin through the use of a service dog helps people with PTSD beyond the tasks the dog also performs. The release of oxytocin eases a handlers anxiety and helps them respond more positively to therapy, offering further support from these well-trained animals.
You May Like: How Long Does It Take To Get A Ptsd Diagnosis
Whats The Different Between An Esd And A Service Dog
The biggest difference to keep in mind is that an ESD is a pet that provides comfort and/or support, and a service dog is highly trained to perform and complete certain tasks. While a service dog may be viewed as a pet by some, its considered a service dog because it is trained to provide a specific function vital to the handlers livelihood.
The following is what defines a service animal, according to the ADA :
Service animals are defined as dogs that are individually trained to do work or perform tasks for people with disabilities. Examples of such work or tasks include guiding people who are blind, alerting people who are deaf, pulling a wheelchair, alerting and protecting a person who is having a seizure, reminding a person with mental illness to take prescribed medications, calming a person with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder during an anxiety attack, or performing other duties. Service animals are working animals, not pets. The work or task a dog has been trained to provide must be directly related to the persons disability. Dogs whose sole function is to provide comfort or emotional support do not qualify as service animals under the ADA.
Service dogs must be allowed to be with their handler at all times. There are very few exceptions to this rule, due to the ADA. The animal, typically a dog, provides a service or does work for someone who is otherwise unable to perform that function without them.