The Difference Between An Utter Eating Disorder And Dieting
97% of dieters regain all of the weight they lose within three years . Further, losing weight doesnt actually improve health biomarkers such as blood pressure, fasting glucose, or triglyceride levels .
Despite these facts, diet fads continue to exist, now adapting to the new health and wellness movement by calling diets lifestyle changes.
Its all the same diet culture negativity with a shiny new package, and it makes interpreting eating behaviors difficult.
Someone may believe that they are successfully adhering to a clean eating diet when they are actually showing symptoms of orthorexia.
Individuals following the ketogenic diet likely have no idea that ketosis itself is a life-threatening condition that indicates insufficient carbohydrate intake.
With this rebranding, how do we tell the difference between these extreme diets or disordered eating?
Below are three hallmarks of both dieting and disordered eating behaviors. The severity of each can mean the difference between a diet or an eating disorder.
When A Diet Becomes An Eating Disorder
- Categorized Other
I just want to lose 10 pounds I want to be able to fit into that dress I want to be able to feel better are common thoughts and phrases that individuals tell themselves when they choose to go on a weight loss diet. Regardless if it is counting calories, restricting carbohydrates or adopting one of the popular diets such as Atkins, South Beach, the Ketogenic diet, or the Paleo diet most individuals choose a diet as a short term fix to lose weight without ever having a desire to adopt an unhealthy relationship with food. Unfortunately, diets are strongly linked to the development of an eating disorder, and according to statistics, 80%-90% of eating disorders begin with a diet a diet that never ends and eventually develops into an unhealthy cycle of binging, purging and restricting. The transition from diet to eating disorder has no single purpose or single cause and usually progresses overtime unintentionally. While diets are generally about food and weight loss, the development of an eating disorder is about gaining a sense of control, numbing painful emotions with food, and earning approval and acceptance from others. Unlike diets, eating disorders do not end when a weight goal is reached because a weight goal will always be set entering into a never-ending cycle of weight loss and body dissatisfaction. The following are critical characteristics between a diet and an eating disorder:
When To Seek Help
Becoming aware of a problematic relationship with food can be difficult. If you find yourself thinking about food all day, unable to control yourself, or find that food impacts your social life, it might be time to seek help. Disordered eating behaviors are treatable with the right resources and help.
Don’t Miss: Does Pristiq Help With Anxiety
Signs And Symptoms Of An Eating Disorder
The level of obsession around eating disorder thoughts and behaviors can distinguish disordered eating from an eating disorder. It is normal to think about or even obsess over food when you are hungry, especially if you have not eaten for a while. It is also normal to think about meal planning, grocery shopping, and cravings for dinner.
This level of obsession with food can impair concentration, the ability to stay present, and can hinder daily functioning. This level of obsession with food, calories, and weight changes and the behaviors that reinforce these obsessions is what differentiates a clinical eating disorder from a disordered eating pattern.
While its difficult to judge how much time and energy another individual spends thinking about food or dieting behaviors, the individual may discuss their thoughts with a friend, or it may be evident through their actions. The following are signs and symptoms associated with eating disorders:
In addition to the obsession, extreme behaviors are prevalent in individuals who have an eating disorder.
From binging and self-induced vomiting to laxative abuse, food restriction, and excessive exercise, individuals will go to extremes on a daily or weekly basis to control their caloric consumption.
This desire for control takes predominance over their lives, and as a result, they may avoid family dinners, outings with friends, or stay home from school or work due to a fear of eating around other people.
When Does Biohacking Become An Eating Disorder
When Jack Dorsey, the CEO of Twitter started fasting through the weekend, he felt like he was hallucinating.Time really slowed down,he told CNBC. In the hours between his five weekly meals, he says, You have this very focused point of mind in terms of this drive.
When Phil Libin, the CEO of an artificial intelligence studio, fasts, he feels a mild euphoria.Im in a much better mood, my focus is better, and theres a constant supply of energy,he told the Guardian.
Kevin Rose, the founder of Digg, launched an app called Zero, to help intermittent fasters track how many hours per day they go without eating.
Fasting evangelists sound straight out of the early chapters of an eating disorder memoir.
Fasting seems to let you harness the highs of self-starvation without getting an eating disorder.
Its probably easier to safely fast if Kate Moss-thin isnt your physical ideal.
Whats bizarre about Silicon Valley fad diets is that women have triedand discardedall of them.
Read Also: What Is The Phobia Of Vomit Called
The Relationship With The Scale
Diet: You are a household object that measures my progress but does not define my self-worth.
Eating disorder: Depending, you are either my best friend or worst enemy.
Individuals who are on a diet will often use a scale to measure their progress. Maybe their goal is to lose 5 pounds in a month, and as a result, they may step on the scale once a week to see if they have made any progress. Some people who diet may not even use a scale but will determine their weight loss progress by how they feel in their clothes. Individuals who are struggling with an eating disorder will use the scale before and after every meal, developing an intense love-hate relationship with the scale to the point that it causes them anxiety and internal pain.
How Do I Find A Clinical Trial
Researchers at the NIMH conduct clinical trials on numerous areas of study, including cognition, genetics, epidemiology, and psychiatry. These clinical trials take place at the NIH Clinical Center in Bethesda, Maryland and may require regular visits. After an initial phone interview, you will come to an appointment at the clinic and meet with a clinician. Visit the NIMH Clinical Trials Participants or Join a Study pages for more information on participating in clinical trials.
To find a clinical trial near you, you can visit www.ClinicalTrials.gov. This website is a searchable registry and results database of federally and privately supported clinical trials conducted in the United States and around the world. ClinicalTrials.gov gives you information about a trial’s purpose, who may participate, locations, and phone numbers for more details. This information should be used in conjunction with advice from health professionals.
Read Also: Does Pristiq Help With Anxiety
Do Differences In Metabolism Body Weight Community Expectations Or Culturally Specific Diets Exist Across Various Cultures
No significant metabolic differences exist between cultural or ethnic groups that explain differing obesity rates. But other factors do have an impact.
Data suggests that when someone moves to the United States, their risk for obesity skyrockets within the first year. I have a friend who came here from Peru when he was about 15 years old. He remembers being amazed by all of the food here. He was stunned by how fast food costs so little. And he couldnt believe how delicious and calorie-dense it was. He became obese and developed high blood pressure within three years. The risk of developing a serious eating disorder for adults who immigrate to the United States remains low. But as kids are raised in American culture, their risk will quickly approach that of the general population.
African Americans are also affected by huge economic and social disparities. These sadly persist and greatly contribute to obesity among that population. Unemployment, incarceration and education rates for African Americans are greatly disadvantaged compared to age adjusted white individuals. It is difficult to imagine prioritizing diet and exercise if your family does not have the luxury of safety or steady jobs.
My Doctor Is Encouraging Me To Become Healthier Doesnt That Mean I Should Lose Weight However I Can
The simple answer is no. Health isnt dictated solely by ones weight. In order to become healthier, you may start engaging in more positive exercise, addressing life concerns, or working on improving your mental, emotional, or psychological health. If a medical professional recommends a patient lose weight in order to live a more fulfilling life it is recommended that the individual meets with a trained dietitian, nutritionist, or even an eating disorder specialist .
Since we know diets dont work, its advised that individuals seek professional guidance when embarking on a path to improve their health. Instead of dieting, doable life changes are suggested as opposed to restrictive changes. One example of promoting health might be reducing the amount of fast food one eats on a weekly basis. This does not mean the individual can never eat fast food or should feel bad if they do, but it encourages the individual to find other options to expand their lifestyle.
Don’t Miss: What Are The Three Stages Of Schizophrenia
Eating Disorders Vs Disordered Eating
The primary delineating factor between disordered eating and a diagnosable eating disorder is the frequency and severity of the abnormal eating pattern. Although both disordered eating and eating disorders are abnormal, eating disorders have very specific diagnostic criteria outlining frequent and severe behaviors.
Up to half of the individuals demonstrate problematic or disordered relationships with food, body, and exercise. We count calories, over-exercise, exercise solely to lose weight, and cringe at the sight of skin folds, thigh dimples, and cellulite. These are normal, and it is time to start normalizing bodies of all shapes and sizes.
Reach Out To A Dietitian And/or Therapist
Its important to work with a professional because of the complicated emotions that can come up when recovering from disordered eating behaviors.
Working to heal the persons relationship with food involves helping the person heal their relationship with their larger sense of self, says Tryon. A therapist and dietitian who specialize in eating disorders will understand this complex relationship and support the person in facing these inner demons, rather than focusing strictly on changing the way the person eats.
Tryon emphasizes finding a provider who specializes in eating disorders and being wary of anyone who says they specialize in weight control or weight loss. If there are no specialists in your area, many dietitians and therapists provide support through telehealth.
Recommended Reading: Define Phobia In Psychology
How Can Family And Friends Help
The most important thing that family and friends can do to help a person who has anorexia is to love them. People who have anorexia feel safe, secure, and comfortable with their illness. Their biggest fear is gaining weight, and gaining weight is seen as loss of control. They may deny they have a problem. People who have anorexia will beg and lie to avoid eating and gaining weight, which is like giving up the illness. Family and friends should not give in to the pleading of the anorexic patient.
Speak Up If Youre Concerned
Its best to reach out as early as possible, since the side effects can get worse as time goes on.
Tryon suggests sending them resources about building a healthy relationship with food or rejecting diet culture. Two recommendations are Health at Every Size by Lindo Bacon and Christy Harrisons Food Psych Podcast.
Recommended Reading: What Is The Phobia For Bees
If Diets Dont Work What Does Work
Deprivation and restriction do not work! Its more about the QUALITY of the calories, rather than the number of calories we eat! Diets are simply not sustainable for the long-term because they do not fulfill individual nutrition needs, based on age, sex, and ethnicity as well as the emotional eating needs if you do not like what you are eating you simply will not stick with it! So instead, forget the calories and focus on food quality.
Cutting back on calories, the time-honored approach to weight loss, will work for the short term. But for most people, this seemingly straightforward approach eventually fails because the body fights back in predictable ways against calorie restriction through rising hunger, slowing metabolic rate, and the production of stress hormones.
What does work is consuming a balanced diet filled with a lager majority of whole foods . Whole foods in their natural state are digested slowly leading to a gradual rise in blood sugar without spiking and crashing. When you eat this way, blood sugar, hormones, and insulin change more gradually after the meal. Fat cells calm down and store less. Hunger decreases. Metabolism speeds up. This is a recipe for long-term weight control without restriction or deprivation.
To achieve this natural, healthy way of eating:
Questions To Ask Your Doctor
Asking questions and providing information to your doctor or health care provider can improve your care. Talking with your doctor builds trust and leads to better results, quality, safety, and satisfaction. Visit the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality website for tips at www.ahrq.gov/patients-consumers.
More information about finding a health care provider or treatment for mental disorders is available on our Finding Help for Mental Illness webpage, available at .
Recommended Reading: Premorbid Schizophrenia
Using Mindfulness To Cope With Difficult Emotions
When you start to feel overwhelmed by negativity, discomfort, or the urge to restrict food, take a moment to stop whatever youre doing and investigate whats going on inside.
Identify the emotion youre feeling. Is it guilt? Shame? Helplessness? Loneliness? Anxiety? Disappointment? Fear? Insecurity?
Accept the experience youre having. Avoidance and resistance only make negative emotions stronger. Instead, try to accept what youre feeling without judging yourself.
Dig deeper. Where do you feel the emotion in your body? What kinds of thoughts are going through your head?
Distance yourself. Realize that you are NOT your feelings. Emotions are passing events, like clouds moving across the sky. They dont define who you are.
Once you learn how to accept and tolerate your feelings, theyll no longer seem so scary. Youll realize that youre still in control and that negative emotions are only temporary. Once you stop fighting them, theyll quickly pass.
For a step-by-step guide to learning how to manage stress and uncomfortable emotions, check out HelpGuides free Emotional Intelligence Toolkit.
Can Eating Disorders Be Prevented Or Avoided
There is no known way to prevent eating disorders. The reason some people develop eating disorders isnt known. People who have anorexia may believe they would be happier and more successful if they were thin. They want everything in their lives to be perfect. People who have this disorder are usually good students. They are involved in many school and community activities. They blame themselves if they dont get perfect grades, or if other things in life are not perfect.
Don’t Miss: What Is The Meaning Of Phobia
Beginning With Your Profession
Before becoming an eating disorder specialist, it is important to decide what profession you wish to practice in, such as a therapist, dietitian, physician, etc. In what ways do you want to serve and treat eating disorder sufferers? Are you more interested in the medical aspect of healing, the therapeutic side of treatment?
If you are unsure what profession might be best for you, consider doing internship work or shadowing a professional who currently works in a position that you might be interested in.
It is also helpful to understand the school criterion for whatever profession you choose to pursue, as this might also influence your decision. If you are choosing a second career, you may be more interested in something that requires minimal schooling, though this is certainly based on personal preference.
When considering a profession that works with the eating disorder population, you may also think about the setting of treatment that interests you. Are you more interested in eating disorder treatment at acute levels of care, like inpatient work or residential treatment?
Tip : Challenge Damaging Mindsets
People with anorexia are often perfectionists and overachievers. Theyre the good daughters and sons who do what theyre told, try to excel in everything they do, and focus on pleasing others. But while they may appear to have it all together, inside they feel helpless, inadequate, and worthless.
If that sounds familiar to you, heres the good news: these feelings dont reflect reality. Theyre fueled by irrational, self-sabotaging ways of thinking that you can learn to overcome.
Also Check: What’s The Phobia Of Throwing Up
Get The Help You Need At Integrative Life Center
We live in a world where fad diets, savvy marketing, and social media surround us with ever-changing images of how a healthy lifestyle looks. We understand societal pressures. Weve seen the effects of fad diets and the fallout.
Making informed choices about nutrition is incredibly important, but not at the cost of mental health.
If you or someone you know shows any signs that the quest for diet perfection is causing significant disruptions in well-being and social life, it could be a sign of Orthorexia.
Prioritize yourself and your future by contacting a member of Integrative Life Center today.
Common Side Effects Of A Restrictive Diet
Now lets look at some of the most prevalent symptoms of malnutrition. They include:
1. An insatiable appetite.
You lose the ability to feel satisfied and this can be really scary.
Where normally you would feel too full, now it seems like you just cant get enough of food no matter how much you eat.
2. Powerful cravings for energy-dense foods.
Your body needs calories, so it craves energy-dense foods.
This is why products like chocolate and cheesecake can be so appealing to frequent dieters.
3. An increased taste response to sugar.
Normally too much sugar tastes sickeningly sweet. Now you can never reach the point where it isnt desirable.
This is because your body has actually increased your taste response to sugar in order to enable you to ingest more calories than your body so desperately needs.
Sugar drink study
A recent scientific study has concluded that when a group of individuals, who fell within the healthy weight range, were given a sweet drink to consume, almost all of them lost the taste for it after a very short time.
The underweight group, however, continued to enjoy it for much longer. This explains why chronic dieters are able to consume huge quantities of sweet foods.
4. Food obsession
Food is all you think about in your car going to and from work, whilst studying, watching TV or chatting with friends.
You may even have food-related dreams.
5. Cravings for stimulants
6. Changes to your brain chemistry
Read Also: What Is The Meaning Of Phobia